Ok, ali ostaje kao činjenica da su najraniji vladari koji se vezuju uz Hrvate imali slavenska imena(Mislav, Branimir, Trpimir, Mutimir itd). To bi značilo ili;
1.da su se Hrvati slavenizirali prije dolaska na Balkan
2.Da su vrlo rano potpuno poslavenjeni na Balkanu prije ikakvih pisanih tragova o njima(od 9.st)
3.da su naprosto otprije slavensko pleme koje je dobilo ime ko zna kako i od koga i s kojim znacenjem.
Dok se Bugari zovu Krum ili Aglobotur dotle Hrvati imaju Trpimira ili Mislava uprosceno govoreci.
A kolege Porga, Porin i sl? Nidles tu sej Buga & Muhlo.
- - - - - - - - - -
PS. Vidiš, ovo od Miloševića može biti korisno za hrvatsku priču (isn't it always):
Early scholars like
Henry Hoyle Howorth believed that Porga was the son of one of five brothers who had left
White Croatia. They noted that the name was uncommon and not of Slavic origin.[SUP]
[1][/SUP] Czech historian
Pavel Jozef Šafárik compared the name to
Purgas, which was the name of a
Mordvins chief mentioned in 1229. Howorth considered that the Croats were subject to "alien princes, perhaps of Avar descent".[SUP]
[1][/SUP]
Franjo Rački considered that Porga could have been a foreign transcription of the Slavic name Borko.[SUP]
[2][/SUP][SUP]
[3][/SUP]
Recently, Serbian historian
Tibor Živković argued that the name comes from the Iranian phrase
pouru-gâo, translated as "rich in cattle",[SUP]
[4][/SUP] while Croatian historian and archaeologist Ante Milošević proposed a new thesis, that the differences in names in chapters 30 and 31 of
De Administrando Imperio are due to differences in folk tradition. According to Milošević, chapter 30 resembles the tradition of the
Longobards, whose first legendary rulers – Godin, Peron, and Klafon – were not actual historical figures, but deities equivalent to Norse
Odin and Balto-Slavic
Perun. In chapter 30, Porin – like Longobard Peron, although probably intended as Porga – wasn't an actual ruler name, but the Slavic deity Perun.[SUP]
[5][/SUP][SUP]
[6][/SUP] Hence, Porin and Porga were two different variants of the deity Perun, and not one or two names of separate historical rulers.[SUP]
[7][/SUP] The thesis was subsequently supported by Denis J. Alimov, who noted that the name of 13th-century Mordvin chief Purgas derives from the deity of thunder Purgin, as well in the 10th-century
Kievan Rus Perun became the supreme deity associated with the ruler.[SUP]
[7]
Dakle, to su upravo ti mitološki Hrvati o kojima je paralelna tema otvorena.
[/SUP]